1 day ago
Wednesday, April 23, 2014
Mary: "Can I help you, sir?"
Mr. Larsson: "Do you have a land-line?"
Mr. Larsson: "I need to make a call, and can't use a cell phone."
Mary: "Okay, that's fine, just come around the counter there."
He sets the plastic box on the counter, comes over to the desk, and starts unbuttoning his shirt.
Mary: "What are you doing?"
Mr. Larsson: "I need to send a pacemaker report to my cardiologist's office, and we don't have a land-line at home."
He tosses his shirt on a chair and starts attaching clips from the box to his chest.
|"Wanna see the scar?"|
Mary: "Um, I don't know how to send a pacemaker report..."
Mr. Larsson: "Can you unplug one of your phone lines and hand me the cord?"
Mrs. Larsson and I finish her appointment. She opens my office door and walks up front.
Mrs. Larsson: "ARNE! PUT YOUR SHIRT ON!"
Mr. Larsson: "But I need to..."
Mrs. Larsson: "NO! I told you, we'll stop at Dr. Senning's office tomorrow, and you can do it directly. You don't need to do this today!"
Mr. Larsson: "But Dr. Grumpy has a land-line!"
Mrs. Larsson: "So does Dr. Senning! Here's your shirt! I'm sorry, Mary, he's just very obsessive about this."
They leave. The door closes. Mary and I stare blankly at each other for about 10 seconds. Then collapse in hysterics.
Tuesday, April 22, 2014
Dr. Grumpy: "It looks like your internist did a pretty decent work-up. Unfortunately, I have to agree with him that she has Alzheimer's disease."
Mr. Amyloid: "Yeah, that's what her daughter and I both figured. What about..."
Lady Amyloid: "We just got married!"
Dr. Grumpy: "Really?"
Mr. Amyloid: "Yep. We've been together for 10 years, but got married last week."
Dr. Grumpy: "Congratulations!"
Mr. Amyloid: "We weren't ever planning on it, but after Dr. Intern told us the news I decided we should while she still knew how much I love her."
After 15 years in this job, it takes a lot to get to me. That did.
Monday, April 21, 2014
For those of you who don't believe this is what American medicine has come to... you should. I've felt the same things other docs have more times than I can count.
For those of you looking to a career in medicine... I repeat what I said last Thursday: GET OUT NOW.
Posted by Grumpy, M.D. at 9:09 PM
Dr. Grumpy: "What happened, sir?"
Mr. Bingo: "I just wanted to get out and do something. Ever since my wife died all I've done is stay at home endlessly and stare at the walls. I just couldn't take it anymore, and wanted to get out. So I went over to the casino."
Dr. Grumpy: "I'm sorry sir. How long ago did your wife die?"
Mr. Bingo: "Yesterday morning."
Friday, April 18, 2014
Thursday, April 17, 2014
$77 billlion dollars.
If you like zeroes, that's $77,000,000,000.
|"Are you sure? That's a lot of zeroes."|
Now, there are roughly 850,000 docs out there who take Medicare. Which means (on average) each of us is getting $90,588.24 from Uncle Sam (this is ONLY Medicare, not other insurance companies).
Of course, that isn't even close to the truth. The released data also shows that 2% of the doctors out there are getting 25% of the take. So for those 2%, they're each getting $4,529,411.76.
As I'd expect, none of those guys are neurologists. And the last number (as big as it is) is peanuts compared to what your average insurance company or hospital CEO got as a Christmas bonus alone.
|"My kid found these. We didn't know what else to do with them."|
So which docs are getting the big Medicare money here?
2. Radiation Oncology
WOW! Those guys must be rich!
Nope, that's not it either.
Figures are misleading. While I believe in transparency, the raw numbers can be manipulated easily to make them show pretty much what anyone (usually a politician) wants.
That giant government payout is, in large part, what they're getting for supplies. These specialties have a few things in common:
1. They're primarily office based.
2. They have high overhead costs.
3. The first three are at high risk of being sued.
4. The first 2 are dealing with horribly sick patients, which cost more money to take care of.
I'm sure you're saying "why isn't neurosurgery on the list?" The office-based cost is the main reason. Most of their good work is in a hospital, and the facility supplies the medical equipment, drugs, staff, and operating room. The surgeon, like me*, shows up and brings her expertise (and the charges for it) with her, but the rest of the costs (and billing for them) get paid to someone else.
*That noise you hear is the horrified inhalation of neurosurgeons because I just mentioned them in the same sentence as neurologists.
So, okay, the oncologists must be rich.
Of course they are! They're part of the secret government-medical conspiracy that's making you smoke tobacco and eat horribly unhealthy food against your will, causing you to get cancer and need their services.
Get real. Yes, they're getting reimbursed a decent chunk of change. But that's gross, not net. Most oncology practices have an office infusion suite to do chemotherapy. This is done there because it's more convenient for the patient, and a helluva lot cheaper for the insurance, to do it in an office than a hospital. But cheaper is a relative term.
Let's look at drugs. One commonly used for breast cancer is Herceptin. This is given once a week, and the list price is $3344 per vial. Another one, Neupogen, is $310 a pop. There's a lot of them like that.
Yeah, but the doctor must charge, like, 2 or 3 times that amount, right? That's why they're rich!
Keep dreaming. You can charge whatever the fuck you want. Medicare will only pay you 106% of the MSRP. Which means, for that $3344 vial of Herceptin, you'll get roughly $3544 back.
So? The doctor is still getting a $200 profit on each vial! That's a lot, you greedy bastards!
Stuff it. Consider the following:
Infusion nurse: $40/hour + benefits.
Infusion chairs: $1500 each.
Mayo stand (a metal table, has nothing to do with condiments): $110 each.
Code cart fully loaded (because disasters happen): $1800 (and it's $1400 to reload it each time it gets used).
Cardiac defibillator (same reason): $1200
IV poles: $70 each
TV set and cable subscription (the patients need something to watch for a few hours)
Wheeled medical stool: $50 each
Then you get into bags of saline, IV tubing, needles, phlebotomy equipment, band-aids, gauze, other medications (Zofran, Benedryl, Phenergan)... you get the idea.
And all of that comes out of the Medicare payments. Of course, the raw number doesn't mention that key point at all.
|"And another thing..."|
Another point: like many docs these days, the oncologist may have an NP or PA seeing patients. Of course, that person is likely working under the doctor's billing ID (called an NPI). So if both of them get, say, $100,000 back from Medicare, it's listed as money that ONLY went to the doc. And what you're seeing doesn't take into account the salary, benefits, and malpractice coverage for the NP, not to mention all the office supplies and support staff.
Wait, so you mean the money meant for 2 or more people can show up in the Medicare data as being all paid to one doc? Exactly. Doesn't give you a clear picture, does it?
The other fields are similar. Radiation oncology? A radiation machine will easily set you back a few million bucks. Not quite the same as say, a sofa from Penny's. But it's necessary in this line of work, because you can't practice without it (trying to irradiate tumors with the stuff you scraped off your kids glow-in-the-dark Halloween costume isn't helpful).
Then you need trained techs to operate it. Federal licenses and certifications to handle radioactive equipment. And a company that supplies/disposes of used isotopes (selling them to Al-Qaeda is frowned upon).
Ophthalmology? Have you ever been to one's office? They don't have something as simple as my Queens Square reflex hammer ($14 on Amazon). The gadgets they use are big, and to fully outfit a decent ophthalmology office will run you $100,000 to $200,000 - before you can even start seeing patients. Having your cataracts done? Each lens costs the doctor from $1000 to $3000 depending on what you need, not including all the other supplies needed for surgery. So a lot of the money is going to cover those expenses, too.
Rheumatology, like oncology, deals with some pricey drugs. Remicade, for example, is $915 a vial from the company.
Then, for ALL doctors, you have to figure in the other office expenses: computers, printers, chart system, staff, office furniture, office machines, paper, pens, coffee maker....
Yeah, but you guys get most of your office supplies free from drug reps! Sorry, Charlie. That practice was banned in 2008. Now the only thing reps can give us is samples, patient education brochures (which I throw away), and a hurried lunch of tuna sandwiches.
Office space alone can eat you alive. Between Pissy and I we have 2100 square feet. And we're paying $5100 a month for that. That's likely more than your mortgage payment for a house of similar size. And our office doesn't have a pool or wet bar.
Malpractice insurance? For non-surgical fields it's anywhere from $30,000 to $100,000 per year (or more). Surgeons? $100,000 to $300,000 (and up) per year depending on the field. That comes out of your share of the $77 billion, too.
Then, when you finally collect your money, a billing company will get 5% to 10% of it.
So, this is not exactly a high-profit-margin field (medical students: GET OUT NOW). A pretty big chunk of the Medicare money goes to cover just the overhead. Running a medical practice is not something you want to do by cutting corners. When things go wrong, they can go VERY wrong.
I'm not looking for sympathy. I'm just trying to make the point that numbers like this are misleading, and can be twisted to mean whatever anyone wants them to. But when you see how much your doctor is getting for taking care of you, that's not all going in his/her personal pocketbook.
Far from it.
But that doesn't stop me, and most of us, from doing our best to care for you, every single day.
Wednesday, April 16, 2014
Tuesday, April 15, 2014
Miss Poppy: "Hi, I need to make an appointment with Dr. Grumpy."
Mary: "Okay, we can see you..."
Miss Poppy: "Wait, first, I need to know if you guys are connected to that big database where you can see which of your patients are getting narcotics from other doctors and when and how many and all that stuff."
Mary: "You mean the state monitoring program? Yes, we are."
Miss Poppy: "Never mind."
Monday, April 14, 2014
Friday, April 11, 2014
Thursday, April 10, 2014
Mr. Waterman: "I need your help. The pharmacy is refusing to give me my seizure medicine! They claim you didn't order it. I know that's a lie, because I saw the doctor do it."
Annie: "Okay, let me look in your chart."
Mr. Waterman: "I'm all out, too."
Annie: "It looks like he wrote a prescription at your visit. Did you give it to them?"
Mr. Waterman: "Did I give what to them?"
Annie: "The prescription he wrote."
Mr. Waterman: "He didn't give me one! He sent it to them."
Annie: "But... In your chart it shows he gave you a handwritten script. What did you do with it?"
Mr. Waterman: "My copy? I tossed it. I didn't think I needed it."
Annie: "That was the prescription! Why did you throw it away?"
Mr. Waterman: "I figured it was sent from his pen as he was writing it."
Wednesday, April 9, 2014
An older gentlemen in a tweed cap comes up to me:
Tweed Cap: "Excuse me, where is the cardiology suite?"
Dr. Grumpy: "Um, there's a cardiologist on the 4th floor, and another on the 8th. Do you know the doctor's name?"
Tweed Cap: "No, my sister had a heart attack earlier, and they told me she was here, in room 745."
Dr. Grumpy: "Oh, you're looking for the hospital. That's across the street."
Tweed Cap: "This isn't the hospital?"
Dr. Grumpy: "No, it's an office building."
Tweed Cap: "It looks like the hospital."
Dr. Grumpy: "No, you have to go outside, head east, and cross the street. There's a foot bridge over traffic."
The elevator opens and I get in it. So does Tweed Cap. I go down to the parking garage under the building and get out. So does Tweed Cap.
Tweed Cap: "So now we are in the hospital?"
Dr. Grumpy: "Uh, no, this is a parking garage."
Tweed Cap: "But it connects to the hospital, doesn't it?"
Dr. Grumpy: "No. See that staircase over there? Take it up 1 flight, and you'll see the hospital right in front of you. There's a bridge across the street there, and you can take it right over."
Tweed Cap: "Thank you."
He got back in the elevator and the doors closed.